Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny Montgomery Tripadvisor Reviews - Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny Montgomery - Kaufe eine Reservierung
Reservierung bei Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny Montgomery für Heute oder Morgen? Geht ganz Easy!
Kaufe eine verifizierte reservierung bei Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny Montgomery von Jemanden der sie nichtmehr braucht.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservierungs!
All listed Reservierungs are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Montgomery's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny Montgomery
Ranked #1 in Montgomery's Best Restaurants.
Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny Montgomery Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
14 Reviews
0 Replys |
It's An Experience Not To Be Missed
The amazing service is truly the special of the house, followed by the menu. If you like an all-star dining experience steeped in ambiance from another time and place - this is the spot for you. Menu prices are $$$, but the portions are generous and sharable. Our favorite items off the menu? Strip steak, mac & cheese and the butter pie. The raw bar looked amazing, too! Go early for nearly private dining and less noise. Before you arrive do your homework on the building and its history - it'll add more to your experience. They accommodate everyone, but holy moly.... Please consider NOT wearing flip-flops,shorts and t-shirts. It ain't that kind of vibe!
Be the first to ReplyGreat Place to Celebrate!
With so many great restaurants around Cincinnati it was a difficult decision in determining where to go on our 55th Anniversary. In the end we settled on Carlo & Johnny and were not disappointed! It was our first time there and didn't know what to expect other than what we had read on Tripadvisor. The positive reviews we read were spot on and all aspects of our visit were positive including the food, service, and atmosphere. Our server, Chris and his assistants, did an outstanding job of taking care of our needs and making our visit not only pleasant but very memorable.
Be the first to ReplyCouldn’t ask for more.
We were celebrating multiple things for our first visit to C&J’s, and had a wonderful experience. It was booked, so we did have to settle for a 4:30 res., but ended up deciding that is not so bad. You just get home earlier. The food was wonderful, and our server Paul and co- server Riann were fabulous. The Honeycomb salad was so original and delicious, and if you like fish- make sure that you try the halibut. I loved that it was piping hot when it arrived at the table, and it was delectable. Nice-sized wine pours as well. We will be back. It’s nice to be treated so well every once in awhile! Wish we could do it more often. It was a special dining experience.
Be the first to ReplyBirthday celebration for our 94 year old grandfather
Everyone from the hostesses to the servers were amazing. Noel was beyond appreciative for the kindness everyone showed him. He loved seeing his name on the menu! We all thought the food was incredible. We all got dessert (butter pie and chocolate cake - took home some cheesecake) and Noel scarfed down the pie while drinking his coffee. Thank you and everyone else at Carlo & Johnny for making his birthday special! He, along with everyone else, really enjoyed themselves.
Be the first to ReplyI expected so much more.
My husband and I read the reviews before deciding where to eat. A lot of customers rated their service impeccable. I agree that the customer service we received was outrageous. We ordered the crab cake as an appetizer-delicious but very small portion for two. My husband ordered the salmon and substituted the artichokes for the Brussel sprouts. He said his Brussel sprouts were charred instead of steamed and that left an aftertaste. His salmon was overcooked and dried out. I ordered the sirloin double burger with fries. It was just ok and the fries were a little too salty. We ordered the cream corn with truffle butter and that was delicious but wasn't served hot. Many customers are very generous with their ratings giving this restaurant 3.8 stars. I can't even give them three stars. I give them 2.5 stars because of the service the food didn't live up to the reputation. The Precinct is better without a doubt better.
Be the first to ReplyA Favorite!
Great location, atmosphere, and service. Food is excellent and consisent! We visit as often as we can!
Be the first to ReplyOne of the most elegant restaurants I have ever been to!
What an elegant restaurant! A beautiful old home, exquisite service, I can’t remember the last time I ate in a restaurant where all of the waiters were in white dinner jackets and black bowties! The manager was very kind and gave us a tour of the beautiful old home and told us all of the history. The food Was excellent, yes it is Expensive but it is so perfect for a special occasion.
Be the first to ReplyA wonderful dining experience!
This is one of my favorite restaurants to visit and well worth the price! The décor inside is cozy and has an art deco feel to it. The servers are so welcoming and attentive and offer some great recommendations. I always have the filet mignon and the mac and cheese, absolutely superb! I highly recommend this place if you're looking to treat yourself and want an excellent fine dining experience. I can't wait to come back!
Be the first to ReplyDelicious steaks and excellent service
Carlo and Johnny was a great experience with wonderful service and exquisite steaks! We've been to Jeff Ruby's in Nashville so when we visited Cincinnati we knew we had to visit one of the restaurants here.
The waiter was more than excellent and provided top notch service.
I had the Delmonico ribeye and my wife had the filet.The steaks were seasoned and cooked perfectly. I have had steaks in 5* restaurants across NYC, Las Vegas, Miami, Boston and other big cities but nothing compares to a Jeff Ruby's steak!
I must include that you have to get the Butter Pie! It is delicious!
CARLO MY WHAT A FANTASTIC PLACE
The wife and I ate here while visiting from out of town for my birthday. Every visits confirms why this is our favorite restaurant.
It is in an old mansion (reportedly mobster owned at one time. There are multiple separate dining rooms. All of which are elegantly and beautifully decorated.
We chose to eat outside in the small enclosed courtyard. The staff was kind enough to bring out 2 space heaters as it was unseasonably cool at night on the Sunday before Memorial Day.
The waitstaff never disappoints. Cameron was charming and attentive without being intrusive. Picture a young Gordan Levitt.
The food is always superb with a perfectly cooked filet and crab stuffed salmon. Our waiter was kind enough to let us know that the salads are available in half portions making it shareable with also splitting the French onion soup. The baby carrots and cacio e pepe complemented the entrees. We received complimentary petit fours to complete our meal.
Overall, this restaurant continues to impress and has replaced the Precinct as our favorite mostly because the service is always a cut above the excellent service at the other locations and the cozy patio setting.
Best experience ever!
My husband and I celebrated our 51st wedding anniversary at Carlo and Johnny! Everything was perfect from the servers to the waiters to the management! The food was awesome! I highly recommend the experience of dining at this restaurant! Thanks to everyone at Carlo and Johnny’s for making our evening a wonderful wonderful experience!
Be the first to ReplyLarge Client Dinner
Food was poorly prepared. Our out-of-town guests were very disappointed and asked us if there was better steak in Cincy? I inquired with the manager and did not receive a response. For important client dinners and events choose an alternative.
Be the first to ReplyReduced occupancy = improved experience
Repeat dining experience. The reduced occupancy has pros and cons. One con is that it takes a while to obtain a reservation. We waited patiently for an opening. The pro is that with fewer patrons packed in one room (yes they do that), the dining experience is less noisy, more relaxed to more intimate. Upon arrival, the valet service and greeting were prompt and courteous. We were immediately seated in a private booth in front of a window with daylight, one of our favorites.
The services, skills and knowledge of the waitstaff are great. We received unbiased advice for the wine choice, which turned out to be a pleasant experience.
The food was served as ordered and desired with appropriate timing for our selection.
All this made for a tasty and pleasant dining experience.
Always an amazing meal at
Always an amazing meal at Carlo and Johnny’s!
Thanks to Chelsey and Brody, and of course Kate and Charlie, for helping to make our night the best.
We started off with oysters that were shucked and cleaned perfectly. They were the best oysters I’ve had in so long. Then onto shrimp, then salads. Moved on to perfectly cooked steaks after that. And if we weren’t full enough, we also had dessert. Our favorite is butter pie, but tonight we added the four layer chocolate cake and crème brûlée. The chocolate cake was the best!
If you want the most perfect dinner every time, then I would suggest going to Carlo & Johnny’s.